論李退溪與李栗谷的「人心道心」之說：以朱子的思想為標準

NHUIR > The Journals of Nanhua University > Aletheia > Item 987654321/27843

Please use this identifier to cite or link to this item: http://nhuir.nhu.edu.tw/handle/987654321/27843

Title:	論李退溪與李栗谷的「人心道心」之說：以朱子的思想為標準
Other Titles:	On Yi Toegye and Yi Yulgok's “renxindoxin”: on the Basis of Standards of Zhu Zi's View
Authors:	陳志杰 Chen, Chih-Chieh
Contributors:	中央大學哲學研究所
Keywords:	朱子;李退溪;李栗谷;人心道心 Zhu Zi;Yi Toegye;Yi Yulgok;renxindoxin
Date:	2021-01-01
Issue Date:	2021-11-17 11:53:25 (UTC+8)
Publisher:	南華大學生死學系哲學與生命教育碩士班
Abstract:	本文擬以探討李退溪與李栗谷的「人心道心」之說與朱子所理解的「人心道心」之差異。退溪認為道心人心之概念可以與「四端七情」進行類比，而栗谷則是重新詮釋了人心道心之思想，提出了「人心道心相為終始」之說。然而退溪與栗谷的「人心道心」之思想都與朱子所理解的有差異，即退溪的人心道心會造成「二心」的問題，但朱子理解的人心道心只是「一心」；而栗谷的人心道心相為終始之說，雖無「二心」的問題，但因為栗谷的人心道心不能並存，故而可能走向「禁慾主義」，此已背於朱子主張的人心道心之說。 The article aims to explore the difference between Yi Toegye(李退溪) and Yi Yulgok(李栗谷)'s theory of “renxindoxin”(人心道心) and Zhu Zi(朱子)'s understanding of “renxindoxin”. Yi Toegye believes that the concept of renxindoxin can be compared with the “four buddings and seven feelings”(四端七情), while Yi Yulgok reinterprets the thought of renxindoxin, and puts forward the theory that “renxindoxin are the beginning and end.”However, the thoughts of “renxindoxin”in Yi Toegye and Yi Yulgok are different from what Zhu Zi understood, that is, Yi Toegye's renxindoxin will cause the problem of “two hearts”, but Zhu Zi's understanding of renxindoxin is only “one heart”; As for Yi Yulgok's renxindoxin as the beginning and end, although there is no problem of “two hearts”, because Yi Yulgok's renxindoxin cannot coexist, it may move towards “Asceticism.”This is contrary to the renxindoxin advocated by Zhu Zi Say.
Relation:	揭諦 40期
Appears in Collections:	[The Journals of Nanhua University ] Aletheia [Department of Life-and-Death Studies] Aletheia

Files in This Item:

File	Description	Size	Format
4012004001.pdf		981Kb	Adobe PDF	431	View/Open
index.html		0Kb	HTML	319	View/Open

Loading...